Local

DNA evidence identifies serial killer in 2 1970s murders; police believe there could be more victims

WASHINGTON COUNTY, Pa. — Pennsylvania State Police say advances in DNA technology have solved two murders that haunted Washington County for nearly five decades, identifying a man investigators say was a serial killer who may have been responsible for other crimes.

Investigators announced Wednesday that DNA evidence identified James Clark Sr. as the man responsible for the 1976 murder of 21-year-old Susan Rush and the 1977 murder of 18-year-old Brenda Ritter.

The two young women were sexually assaulted and strangled six months apart. Despite extensive investigations and numerous leads, neither case resulted in an arrest.

Clark was never identified as a suspect in either investigation. He was living in the Washington area at the time of the murders and was 19 and 20 years old when the crimes occurred, according to state police.

He died in 2023 at the age of 66.

The DNA breakthrough has also raised the possibility that investigators may be dealing with a much larger series of crimes. Police say Clark worked as a long-haul truck driver, traveling throughout the country, and investigators are now examining whether he could be connected to other unsolved cases.

“I believe once you are a serial killer, there could be more victims out there,” said Corporal James Petrosky of Pennsylvania State Police.

Rush was 21 years old and working at G.C. Murphy’s at the Washington Mall when she disappeared on Wednesday, Nov. 24, 1976.

She left work at approximately 6:10 p.m. and was expected to meet family members at a church for a Thanksgiving Eve dinner. She never arrived.

After her family reported her missing, investigators found her vehicle on North Avenue in Washington.

Rush’s body was discovered in the trunk of her car. An autopsy determined she had been sexually assaulted and strangled.

Investigators pursued numerous leads and persons of interest, but the case remained unsolved.

Six months later, another young woman was found murdered under similar circumstances.

Brenda Ritter, 18, worked as a secretary for a company in Washington.

On May 18, 1977, Ritter left her boyfriend’s home at approximately 10:10 p.m. and headed home during a thunderstorm. Her boyfriend and his mother made sure she locked her car doors before leaving.

Her abandoned vehicle was later discovered along Rankin Road, near Zediker Station Road, in North Strabane Township.

Ritter’s body was found approximately three-quarters of a mile from her vehicle.

Like Rush, Ritter had been sexually assaulted and strangled.

For decades, investigators continued working both cases, preserving evidence that would eventually be tested using technology that did not exist when the women were killed.

In 2008, specific evidence from Ritter’s murder was submitted to the Pennsylvania State Police crime laboratory. Investigators developed an unidentified male DNA profile and uploaded it into the FBI’s Combined DNA Index System, known as CODIS.

The DNA profile was searched against the database on a weekly basis, but initially produced no match.

In 2022, Pennsylvania State Police received grant funding through the Bureau of Justice Assistance’s Prosecuting Cold Cases Using DNA program. The funding allowed investigators to pursue additional testing through an outside laboratory.

In May 2025, additional DNA testing was conducted by CyberGenetics.

The testing ultimately produced a match to a DNA offender profile, identifying Clark as the person responsible.

Investigators then determined the same offender was responsible for both murders.

“The testing identified the same offender murdered both,” Petrosky said. “This testing confirmed there was a serial killer in Washington County during that time.”

State police emphasized that evidence from cold cases is carefully maintained and can be revisited as forensic technology continues to advance.

While the identification of Clark brings answers to two long-unsolved murders, investigators say the discovery could have implications far beyond Washington County.

Clark was a long-haul truck driver, spending significant time on the road and traveling through other states.

Police are now looking into whether he could be connected to other unsolved murders.

Investigators have not identified any additional victims, but Petrosky said he believes the possibility should not be dismissed.

“Once a serial killer, always a serial killer. I believe there could potentially be more victims out there,” he said.

Investigators have not determined whether Clark targeted the women or whether the attacks were random.

The announcement brought renewed attention to two murders that left a lasting impression on women throughout the Washington area.

More than 50 years later, many still remember the fear surrounding the killings.

One woman recalled on social media that she remembered the murders clearly, writing that parents would not allow their teenage daughters to go out alone.

Another wrote that she had thought of the two women many times over the years.

A third remembered being afraid to leave work at night, saying the entire area was on alert.

Download the FREE WPXI News app for breaking news alerts.

Follow Channel 11 News on Facebook and Twitter. | Watch WPXI NOW

0